Hawaii Credit Card Surcharge Laws

Quick Summary:

• Credit card surcharging has restricted legality in Hawaii
• Hawaii law generally prohibits surcharges when credit cards are used instead of cash, check, or similar payment methods
• Surcharges may be allowed in other specific scenarios where cards aren't replacing traditional payment methods
• Cash discounts are permitted as an alternative to surcharging
• Violations can result in enforcement action through Hawaii's consumer protection agencies

Hawaii's credit card surcharge regulations create a nuanced legal landscape that differs from many other states. While Nickel helps businesses navigate payment processing efficiently, understanding Hawaii's specific restrictions on surcharging helps B2B companies and accounting professionals make informed decisions about their payment strategies.

The state has taken a consumer protection approach that limits when businesses can add fees for credit card payments, though the enforcement and interpretation of these rules has evolved over time.

Legal Disclaimer: This information is for reference only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult with an attorney before implementing any surcharge programs, as rules and enforcement can change.

Is Credit Card Surcharging Legal in Hawaii?

Credit card surcharging is generally prohibited in Hawaii when customers elect to use credit cards "in lieu of payment by cash, check, or similar means." This restriction comes from Hawaii's consumer protection framework, though the exact statutory language and enforcement has been subject to legislative consideration over the years.

Under Hawaii's approach, businesses cannot impose surcharges on cardholders who choose credit cards as an alternative to traditional payment methods. However, the law does allow for some flexibility in specific circumstances where credit cards aren't being used as substitutes for cash or check payments.

Hawaii's position aligns with consumer protection goals seen in other states that have restricted surcharging, focusing on preventing businesses from penalizing customers for using convenient payment methods.

What's Allowed

Hawaii businesses can implement these payment strategies within the legal framework:

• Cash discount programs - Offer lower prices for customers paying with cash, check, or other non-credit payment methods
• Multi-tiered pricing - Display different prices for various payment methods, as long as credit card prices aren't presented as surcharges
• Convenience fees for alternative channels - In specific situations where credit cards provide genuine alternative payment channels beyond standard merchant practices
• Government and utility exceptions - Certain government entities may have different rules for utility charges and public service payments

What's Not Allowed

Hawaii's consumer protection approach prohibits these practices:

• Traditional credit card surcharges - Adding fees when customers choose credit cards instead of cash or check payments
• Hidden fees - Any undisclosed charges that appear during the payment process
• Third-party guarantee fees - Charges for credit card guarantee services that function as surcharges
• Discriminatory pricing - Penalizing customers specifically for credit card usage when other payment methods are standard

Penalty For Non-Compliance

Hawaii enforces payment-related consumer protection through multiple channels:

• Consumer complaints can be filed with the Hawaii Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs Office of Consumer Protection
• Civil enforcement actions may be pursued by state consumer protection agencies
• Industry oversight through existing merchant agreement compliance requirements
• Federal oversight continues to apply for businesses operating across state lines

Consumers experiencing improper surcharging can file complaints by calling (808) 586-2653 or through the online complaint system.

Hawaii Credit Card Surcharge FAQs

Does Hawaii's surcharge restriction apply to all types of businesses?

The restriction applies broadly to retailers and service providers conducting sales transactions with consumers. However, certain government entities and utilities may have different rules, particularly for payments to public agencies. The restriction focuses on consumer transactions rather than specialized B2B payment arrangements.

Can Hawaii businesses offer cash discounts instead of credit card surcharges?

Yes, cash discount programs are specifically allowed under Hawaii's framework. Businesses can offer discounts for cash, check, or other non-credit payment methods as long as these discounts are offered to all prospective buyers. This approach achieves similar cost recovery goals without technically "surcharging" credit card users.

How do Hawaii's rules affect online and phone transactions?

The consumer protection principles apply to all transaction types, but Hawaii recognizes that certain remote transactions may inherently require credit card payments. When businesses only accept credit cards for phone or online orders (rather than offering cash alternatives), the surcharge restrictions may not apply since consumers aren't "electing" credit cards over other available options.

What should contractors and wholesale distributors know about Hawaii's surcharge laws?

B2B businesses operating in Hawaii should be particularly careful about payment terms in their contracts. While consumer protection laws primarily target retail transactions, the safest approach for businesses processing large invoice-based payments is to build credit card processing costs into standard pricing rather than adding surcharges. Nickel's free ACH payment processing can help Hawaii businesses avoid credit card fees entirely on qualifying transactions.

How do federal regulations interact with Hawaii's surcharge restrictions?

Federal law allows surcharges up to 4% of transaction value, but Hawaii's state restrictions take precedence for businesses operating within the state. This means Hawaii businesses must comply with the more restrictive state framework. However, card network rules (Visa, Mastercard) still apply and may impose additional requirements beyond state law.

‍